Four Whats
Four questions that check whether a project is actually ready: what we have, what we are missing, what could block us, what we can learn from.

- Time
- 1–1.5 hours
- People
- Whole core team
Overview
A readiness check, not a framing exercise. Four questions in sequence — what we have, what we are missing, what could block us, what we can learn from — that surface the resources, gaps, risks and prior art around a project before anyone commits to a plan.
Its value is that it asks about capability rather than ambition. Most discoveries that go wrong were not badly framed; they were started without something they needed, and nobody said so out loud in week one.
When to use it.
In pre-framing, once there is a rough brief. Also worth running mid-project when a team feels stuck and cannot say why — usually the answer is sitting in “what could block us”.
Who to involve.
The whole core team, plus anyone who has worked on the problem before. The fourth round depends on somebody in the room remembering the last attempt.
Effort.
Low prep High engagement Sustained for the whole core team across four rounds back to back, with a buffer between them.
Outcomes.
A named list of resources you can draw on, gaps that need owners, risks worth mitigating, and prior work to connect with. The fourth round routinely turns up an internal team already halfway through the same problem. Together, the four rounds align the working group and build its confidence in what has already been done and what resources are available — building up the project’s baseline and the pre-read for framing.
Recommendations.
Three to five minutes really is enough — the constraint makes people write the obvious thing first, which is usually the true thing. Silent-first stops the most senior voice setting the list. And turn rounds 2 and 3 into a list with names against it: a gap nobody owns is a gap you have documented rather than closed. Allow space for open discussion, but keep an eye on the time: this is also where resources that nobody wrote on a sticky get named out loud in conversation, so follow up on anything mentioned that did not make it onto the board.
How to run it
Each round follows the same shape: three to five minutes of silent individual listing, then open discussion as a group. Move straight from one question to the next.
What we have
5 minutes What essential resources or elements for the project do you already have?
What we are missing
5 minutes What essential resources or elements do you need?
What could block us
10 minutes What could hinder the project? Longer, because this is the round that earns the exercise its keep. The board’s own note on it: understanding is half the battle.
What we can learn from
10 minutes What previous projects or competitors have solved similar problems, and what can we learn from them? Are there ongoing internal projects we should connect with?


